Dear Leader Key blames everyone else for Solid Energy’s financial crisis (Part Rua)
Opposition Party members of the Commerce Select Committee are demanding that ex-CEO, Don Elder appear before the Select Committee to answer questions what went wrong at Solid Energy.
With unanswered questions about Solid Energy’s financial crisis; a murky history leading up to current events; big bonuses paid out as the company’s accounts were sinking into the red; and revelations that Don Elder is still recieving his $1.3 million annual salary – whilst working from home “serving out his notice” – pressure is mounting on National.
Solid Energy went from a multi-billion dollar company to being heavily indebited to $389 million.
How did this happen?
Did ministerial shareholders Bill English and Tony Ryall not notice?
Were they not receiving reports from Solid Energy’s Board of Directors?
Were no rumours or conversations floating around?
How does one keep a secret like that in a small country like New Zealand? (In which case should Solid Energy take over our country’s security, from the GCSB and SIS?)
Why were we paying Don Elder for ($1.3 million p.a., plus bonuses no doubt) if not to be held to account?
On 8 March, Key was reported as saying,
“If he wants to go [to the Select Committee hearings] and they want him to go he is not going to get any opposition from my office.”
And SOE Minister chipped in with this,
“It’s a matter for the Commerce Select Committee, Solid Energy and Dr Elder whether or not Dr Elder attends, but I don’t have a problem either way.”
Good. Because the public – who own Solid Energy – deserve answers. Thus far all we’ve had is the usual finger-pointing by National, with childishly pathetic attempts to blame Labour for Solid Energy’s woes. As if Labour was still in government and the 2008 and 2011 general elections never happened.
This statement from Key, on 26 February 2013, simply doesn’t wash,
“They [Labour] can’t wash their hands of the fact that from 2003 on, they were intimately involved with the plans that that company had.
The argument that somehow we would have gone in, in 2009 when the company was performing well, its results were good, the valuation of the company was going up, and just gone and sacked the board on day one is a bit fanciful.
Maybe we should have re-tested those [Labour-approved] initiatives but actually we gave [Labour] the benefit of the doubt that they might get one thing right.”
That was ten years ago! What has National been doing in the meantime?
As far back as September 2011, the Nats were abundantly aware that Solid Energy was embarking on expansion plans,
Solid Energy starts work at Mataura Briquette Plant
Friday, 9 September 2011, 2:57 pm
Press Release: Solid Energy NZ
9 September 2011
Solid Energy marks the start of work at its Mataura Briquette Plant
The Hon Bill English, MP for Clutha-Southland and Minister of Finance, today marked the official start of work at Solid Energy’s Mataura Briquette Plant, by “turning the first sod” at a small event on site with neighbours, local authorities, and other guests.
The $25 million Mataura briquette plant is planned to start production by June 2012. It will produce up to 90,000 tonnes a year of low-moisture and higher-energy briquettes from about 150,000 tonnes of lignite mined from Solid Energy’s New Vale Opencast Mine and trucked to the Craig Road site. The plant will use technology developed in the USA by GTL Energy.
Here’s the photographic evidence, from National’s own ‘Flickr’ account, same date, 9 September 2011 – that’s Finance Minister Bill English, “turning the first sod of earth” for Solid Energy’s Mataura Briquette Plant in Southland. That plant was part of their expansion plans,
Only three months earlier, in June 2011, Key himself was supporting Solid Energy’s explansion plans,
Note Key’s comment in the above article in the National Business Review (hardly a leftist rag),
“At the moment companies like Solid Energy are growth companies and we want them to expand in areas like lignite conversion.”
So for Dear Leader to blame Labour is not only disingenuous – it is cowardly.
It shows the entire country that the man who is supposedly or Prime Minister hasn’t got the balls to take it on the chin and admit that he and his Party f****d up. Big time.
Even the editorial from the Dominion Post said, with unconcealed exasperation on 2 March 2013,
There are always excuses when a company starts to fail. John Key’s explanation for the trouble at Solid Energy, however – he blamed the Labour government – was pitiful.
It was Trevor Mallard’s fault, apparently, for encouraging SOEs to spread their wings and fly. That was in 2007 or 2008.
This won’t do, and not just because Mr Key’s Government has been in power for more than four years. His argument also contradicts itself. A Labour government was seemingly omnipotent and could have its way with the state-owned coal company. But National had no such power.
The Government certainly said no when Solid Energy asked for a billion dollars to turn itself into a super-company along the lines of Petrobras, the Brazilian giant. Mr Key says it had grave doubts about the company’s expansion plans. His political opponents point out that he and Bill English had publicly backed Solid Energy’s big plans for lignite conversion and briquetting.
This blogger welcomes Don Elder fronting up to the Commerce Select Committee. However, that is simply not sufficient. In the interests of full justice, the following should occur,
- John Key should front up and answer questions as well,
- Bill English should front up and answer questions,
- Tony Ryall should front up and answer questions,
- All documentation should be made available to the Committee,
- The Chairperson of the Select Committee – National MP Jonathan Young, should stand aside and be replaced by a non-partisan senior judge or Queen’s Counsel,
- If necessary, if the Committee is unable to answer questions, a full Royal Commission in Inquiry should be held.
National prides itself on being the party of ‘personal responsibility‘. It is no such thing. It is the party of personal advantage and not much more.
Thus far all we’ve had are evasiveness and pathetic attempts to blame others. We’re also seeing more of the same from our Prime Minister; bullshit.
Previous related blogposts
NZ National Party: Solid Energy chief executive, Don Elder and Hon Bill English at Mataura (9 Sept 2011)
Scoop.co.nz: Solid Energy starts work at Mataura Briquette Plant (9 Sept 2011)
NBR: Key supports Solid Energy’s lignite plans (3 June 2011)
TV3: Govt, Labour squabble over Solid Energy (26 Feb 2013)
Dominion Post: Editorial: Solid Energy excuses fuel anger (2 March 2013)
TVNZ: Pressure grows on Don Elder to front over Solid Energy (8 March 2013)
Fairfax media: Minister, PM fine for Elder to appear for grilling (8 March 2013)
= fs =
For a better New Zealand…
~ Cleaner rivers
~ No deep-sea oil drilling
~ Less on Roads - more on Rail
~ A Living wage at $18.40/hr
~ Marriage equality - Yay! Got that one!
~ Strong, effective Unions
~ No secret free-trade deals
~ Breakfast/lunches in our schools
~ Introducing Civics into our school curriculum
~ Cut back on the liquor industry
~ A fairer, progressive tax system
~ Fully funded, free healthcare
~ Ditto for education, including Tertiary
~ Fund Pharmac for Pompe's Disease medication & other 'orphan' drugs
~ No state asset sales!
~ Rebuild public TV broadcasting!
~ Keeping farms in local ownership
~ Reduce poverty, like we reduced the toll for road-fatalities
~ Jobs, Jobs, Jobs!
~ Being nice to each other
- Farewell, Nelson Mandela…
- I’ve voted – have you?
- John on John…
- A letter to the editor…
- Bring in the clowns…
- Radio NZ: Politics with Matthew Hooton and Mike Williams – 2 December 2013
- The ChCh by-election – a letter to the editor…
- Another “satisfied” WINZ client…
- Full access for everyone!
- Geoff Robinson – an era ends.
- Radio NZ: Politics with Matthew Hooton and Mike Williams – 25 November 2013
- Radio NZ: Focus on Politics for 22 November 2013
- 2013 – Ongoing jobless talley
- One Dunedinite’s response to the passing of the GCSB Bill…
- Random Thoughts on Random Things #5…
- Random Thoughts on Random Things #4…
- Random Thoughts on Random Things #3…
- Random Thoughts on Random Things #2…
- Random Thoughts on Random Things #1…
- Another good poll for a LabourGreen government
- Radio NZ: Politics with Matthew Hooton and Mike Williams – 30 September 2013
- Endorsing Celia for Mayor
- How To Guide: Voting in Auckland
- Guest Author: Dunedin election – my guide to who’s left and who’s not
- Endorsing Jeanette for ADHB!
- December 2013
- November 2013
- October 2013
- September 2013
- August 2013
- July 2013
- June 2013
- May 2013
- April 2013
- March 2013
- February 2013
- January 2013
- December 2012
- November 2012
- October 2012
- September 2012
- August 2012
- July 2012
- June 2012
- May 2012
- April 2012
- March 2012
- February 2012
- January 2012
- December 2011
- November 2011
- October 2011
- September 2011
- August 2011
- July 2011