Home > The Body Politic > Letter to the editor – So this is ‘job creation’ by foreign ownership?

Letter to the editor – So this is ‘job creation’ by foreign ownership?


Frank Macskasy - letters to the editor - Frankly Speaking


This is not the news that towns and regions across the country want to wake up to;


Shock in Invercargill as meatworks shuts


The Radio NZ report continues;

Prime Range was taken over 15 months [November 2014] ago by a Chinese-backed company, Lianhua Trading Group, which itself could be troubled.

Its shares had been put into receivership and it had changed directors several times since the deal.

The Meat Workers Union said the firm had run out of money because its investors had been caught up in turmoil on the Chinese stock exchange.

Invercargill MP Sarah Dowie has called on Prime Range to tell its suspended workers what is going on.

Ms Dowie said she had received messages from distraught families and the situation was hard on them.

Work and Income New Zealand was on standby for workers as a safety net, but she hoped issues would be resolved as soon as possible.

No one from the company, nor its directors, returned calls from RNZ News.

I’ll bet that “no one from the company, nor its directors, returned calls from RNZ NewsCountries like China are not noted for engaging with media and explaining what is happening to their workers.

The fate of Prime Range prompted me to share these observations with The Southland Times;


from: Frank Macskasy <fmacskasy@gmail.com>
to: The editor <letters@stl.co.nz>
date: Thu, Feb 18, 2016
subject: Letter to the editor


The editor
Southland Times


One hundred and thirty workers at Prime Range Meats have been suspended, with no guarantee that they will be able to return to work. This is the fall-out after Prime was purchased by foreign investors in November 2014.

The situation for these 130 workers is dire, with no income, and no money with which to buy food or pay their bills. How they are able to survive is a miracle in itself.

In all this mess, where is Southland’s former MP, Bill English? Despite abdicating his role as MP for Southland, and becoming a sole-List MP in 2014, one would expect that he has at least a moral duty to step in and sort out this mess.

After all, it was Bill English who, in March 2009, said,

“Overseas investment can play an important role in economic recovery and job creation” (Beehive: ‘Government to simplify foreign investment rules’)

In this case, overseas investment has factored in job destruction, putting many Southland families into financial strife.

Bill English needs to step up. He has advocated for foreign investment and takeover of local companies. Now he needs to take responsibility.


-Frank Macskasy

[address and phone number supplied]


In justifying the need for foreign investment, and consequential buy-up of local companies and other assets, Bill English said in Parliament on 13 February 2013;

“…New Zealand has not, for many decades, had sufficient savings to fund all of its own investment.”

Mr English is 100% correct in  this; New Zealand has not had sufficient savings to fund all of its own investment. Not since National abandoned Labour’s superannuation savings scheme in 1975;


Compulsory super 'would be worth $278b' - fairfax media - National Govt incompetance


Fortyone years later, we are still paying for National’s short-sightedness and fiscal imprudence.







Radio NZ: Shock in Invercargill as meatworks shuts

Beehive: Hon Bill English

Beehive: Government to simplify foreign investment rules

Parliament: Hansards – Economic Growth and Job Creation – Progress and Foreign Direct Investment

Fairfax media: Compulsory super ‘would be worth $278b’


Radio NZ: 130 meatworkers wait for news after suspension

Radio NZ: Meat workers in limbo after sudden suspension

Radio NZ: Suspended meatworker’s wife says 130 families are struggling

NZ Herald: Decision lies with farmers, says English

Related blogposts

Kiwis, Cows, and Canadian singers

That was Then, this is Now #10




This blogpost was first published on The Daily Blog on 20 February 2016.



= fs =

  1. truthseekernz
    25 February 2016 at 9:08 am

    Surely by now anyone who has been paying attention can see that foreign ownership leads to – at least – the running down of the local business followed by it’s relocation elsewhere…..along with whatever intellectual property was sold.

    Navman, anyone? Along with a long list of Kiwi start-ups that reached a certain point….were sold off….and then soon disappeared from our shores.

    Right down to toothpaste. We don’t even make such a simple everyday item here anymore. All bought off or killed by overseas interests or owners.

  2. Samwise
    26 February 2016 at 11:12 am

    Latest media reports indicate that farmers will be forced into mortgagee sales with overseas buyers waiting to snap them up. We are becoming not just tenants in our own country, but unemployed tenants. This is what New Zealanders voted for when they ticked National last election.

  1. No trackbacks yet.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: