Home > The Body Politic > Horizon Polling on Criminalising sea-going protests

Horizon Polling on Criminalising sea-going protests

.

Horizon Poll - Crown Mineral Bill - sea protests

Note: this header-image above was not partof the Polling Questionnaire in any way, shape, or form. Are you paying attention, Slater? Step awaaaaay from the computer terminal…

.

As the proposed amendment to the Crown Minerals Bill – which will criminalise sea-going protests  – nears enactment, Horizon Research this week conducted a brief poll on the issue.

The questions – and this blogger’s answers – were as follows…

Firstly, Horizon Research presented a summary of facts which was reasonably impartial and gave the respondent a fairly clear idea as to the issues,

.

Horizon Poll - Crown Minerals Bill

.

The first two questions were fairly straight forward, and I gave my answer as “Strongly Opposed” to the proposed law changes.

For me, the amendments to the Crown Minerals bill can be summed up as,

  • procedurally flawed, as National ministers make no allowance for public submissions so that people can air their views,
  • undemocractic in the extreme,
  • draconian in content, and more reminiscent of Putin-era Russia, than a liberal democracy,
  • hastily-enacted, making laws that are  inevitably flawed.

.

Horizon Poll - Crown Minerals Bill - sea protests - simon bridges - criminalising protest

.

Horizon then asked me to explain why I opposed the proposed legislative amendment. (Bad mistake – I’m not shy in expressing my views)

Thankfully there was no word limit in the field. I responded accordingly,

.

Horizon Poll - Crown Minerals Bill - sea protests - simon bridges - criminalising protest

.

The next question was fairly complex, with multiple options for answers. I had to pick each option carefully,

.

Horizon Poll - Crown Minerals Bill - sea protests - simon bridges - criminalising protest

.

The following question was easy to answer,

.

Horizon Poll - Crown Minerals Bill - sea protests - simon bridges - criminalising protest

.

The next question was a follow-up with a request to explain my previous response,

.

Horizon Poll - Crown Minerals Bill - sea protests - simon bridges - criminalising protest

.

This one was obvious,

.

Horizon Poll - Crown Minerals Bill - sea protests - simon bridges - criminalising protest

.

Also a straight forward question,

.

Horizon Poll - Crown Minerals Bill - sea protests - simon bridges - criminalising protest

.

And this question really allowed me to ‘let rip’ with my thoughts on this issue,

.

Horizon Poll - Crown Minerals Bill - sea protests - simon bridges - criminalising protest

.

An incoming Labour-Green government  will have a full legislative agenda, repealing many of  National’s undemocratic laws. As with the “Hobbit Law” (which Labour has pledged to repeal – see: Labour vows to repeal Hobbit Law), there are many pieces of legislation which have no place in a liberal democracy, and should be binned as soon as Labour Ministers are sworn into office.

.

Horizon Poll - Crown Minerals Bill - sea protests - simon bridges - criminalising protest

.

It would be interesting to learn who the client  (if any) was for this poll.

Continuede at: Horizon Polling on Criminalising sea-going protests – Part Rua

Addendum

In what has been one of the fastest pieces of law-making in New Zealand’s history,  the Crown Minerals (Permitting and Crown Land) Amendment Bill passed its third reading in Parliament at 4.30pm today (16 April)  by 61 votes to 59. Next step; the Bill will proceed to  the Governor General for assent and become law.

This ain’t democracy, folks. This is government-by-decree.

.

*

.

References

NZ Herald: Protester law avoids public submissions and Bill of Rights vetting  (3 April 2013)

Previous related blogpost

Meanwhile, back on Planet Key

To be followed up at The Daily Blog

See upcoming blogpost:  National’s disdain for democracy and dissent

.

.

= fs =

Advertisements
  1. 16 April 2013 at 9:33 pm

    This ain’t democracy, folks. This is government-by-decree.

    That’s standard National. Pure bloody authoritarian to the bone. It’s amazing how many people don’t realise that.

    The results were released today.

    • 17 April 2013 at 10:04 pm

      Damn straight, Draco.

      And they had the cheek to complain about Labour’s so-called “nany statism” in 2007/08… I think I prefer Nanny State to Fascist State any day…

  2. SpaceMonkey
    17 April 2013 at 11:46 am

    It’s like living under an FPP Government again.

    • 17 April 2013 at 10:03 pm

      Indeed, SM. The “brakes” that MMP offered have instead become an extra “gear” for the government to speed up.

      With Dunne and Banks, any “brake” on National policy-making is an illusion.

      All we can hope for is that a new centre-left government will review these pieces of legislation and dump those that are alien to our concepts of justice and democracy. (Otherwise why have a change in government?)

  3. Tom Sawyer
    18 April 2013 at 12:19 am

    So I wonder who commissioned that survey? Someone desperately wants to find out public opinion on this issue!

  1. 17 April 2013 at 6:00 pm

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: