Archive
Don – stop smoking that ‘Kronic’!!
Don Brash, Leader of ACT Party
Don Brash, on Q+A today (21 August),
“Nobody seriously believes that Governments run commercial business better than private owners do. There is no logic at all for Governments to continue to own them.”
Really, Don?
Let’s do a Fact Check on your claim that “nobody seriously believes that Governments run commercial business better than private owners do”.
Case # 1: Air New Zealand.
In April 1989 the airline was privatised by Roger Douglas with a sale to a consortium consisting of; Brierley Investments Ltd(65%), Qantas (19.9%), Japan Air Lines Ltd (7.5%), and American Airlines Ltd (7.5%) .
The owners were a fairly high-powered, supposedly commercially-saavy, group of corporations.
Sources:
The sale went through, earning the State $660 million.
In 2000, Air New Zealand entered into a commercial deal to buy 100% Ansett Airlines, for $A680 million, from Rupert Murdoch’s News Corporation Ltd. This deal went sour and Ansett Australia was placed into liquidation by September 2000. Air New Zealand subsequently announced a $NZ1.425 billion operating loss .
By October 2001, Air New Zealand was itself in imminent danger of collapsing and was re-nationalised by the then Clark-led Labour government under a NZ$885 million bail-out. The government ended up with a 76.5% stake.
So much for private ownership.
Case #2: NZ Rail
In September 1993, NZ Rail was privatised and sold for $400 million (less debt) to a consortium consisting of Wisconsin Central (40%), Berkshire Partners III L.P. (20%), and Fay & Richwhite (40%). NZ rail then had a succession of owners, culminating in heavy losses, with a $346 million loss for the half-year ended December 2003.
In May 2008 the Labour Government agreed to buy Toll NZ Ltd (less its trucking and distribution operations) for $665 million.
This experiment in privatisation was also a spectacular failure. No private owner could make a profit, even with the government agreeing in 2003 to spend $200 million over the following five years, upgrading the track via the new SOE, Ontrack.
The rail network had been badly run down through lack of investment in new rolling stock and lack of basic maintenance. And one of it’s first private owners, David Richwhite were investigated late 2004, by the NZ Securities Commission, regarding alleged insider trading. In June 2007 Richwhite agreed to pay NZ$20 million, but did not admit liability.
Another “Tui time” for private ownership of state assets.
Case #3: Finance Companies.
It might be worthwhile reminding Don that the recent chain of collapse of finance companies in this country cost investors $6 – $8 billion dollars in losses . Many of these are the real “Mums and Dads” investors that National speaks lovingly when mooting asset sales.
So Don, spare us the rhetoric that “nobody seriously believes that Governments run commercial business better than private owners do”. Because as many will confirm – that’s bullshit.
The question I ask myself is; Don, do you really believe that fantasy or not. If you do, you are deluded. If you don’t, you are deliberately mis-representing the truth.
Either way – not a good look, mate.