“Dopey is as dopey does”, according to Dear Leader
For a man who was raised in a state house; in a single-parent family; and who had all the benefits of a free tertiary education, John Key’s attitude towards those at the bottom of the socio-economic scale leaves a lot to be desired.
- John Key’s father died, leaving his mother a solo-mum, to raise children by herself,
- She would have received the DPB or widow’s benefit (and quite rightly so)
- She would most likely have been eligible for the Family Benefit, paid to families with children until Ruth Richardson scrapped it in her 1991 “Mother of all Budgets”
- John Key’s family enjoyed a state house, with low-rent and security of tenure
- And lastly, John Key was given a free, tax-payer funded University education (no student fees or debt)
When the Children’s Commissioner’s Expert Advisory Group (EAG) report was released, it’s recommendations included,
“ First, the group will call for a Warrant of Fitness for landlords. Given John Key has this weekend stressing the success of the Green-inspired home insulation scheme, but the disappointing uptake from landlords, it’s a timely bit of advice.
A WOF on rental homes would ensure poor kids don’t grow up in leaky, cold and unhealthy homes. Really, a safe, warm house should be a basic requirement if you’re going to charge rent. Who can argue with that?
Second, it’ll call for meals to be provided more widely in schools. Some, such as Deborah Morris-Travers from Every Child Counts says that’s a no-brainer. Children need food if they’re to learn and deal with the social demands of school. Some are less keen, however, arguing it takes the onus off parents and puts more pressure on teachers to feed as well as teach our children.
But another study shows this could just be the thin end of the school wedge. Every Child Counts’ Netherlands study this week talked about schools becoming a community hub, with not only meals but before and after school care, nurses, social workers and clubs.
It’s a bold prescription, but one that works overseas by helping working parents and keeping families connected to their schools.
Third, the EAG is expected to call for some form of long-term and universal state assistance for kids – maybe a Universal Child Benefit, or some money every week for every child born. Until 1991 we had such a thing – a Family Benefit. That went in the Bolger/Richardson years. “
These three options could put a serious dent into child poverty. A Universal Child Benefit – along the lines of the old Family Benefit – could add an extra $150 and extra food on the tables of low-income families.
John Key’s response? In Parliament, responding to a point made by Greens co-leader, Metiria Turei [error correction], he bellowed with great gusto,
“We are in an unequal society in New Zealand in her view because the rich are getting richer. And now she is on her feet telling me ‘give the rich families even more for their kids’. What a dopey idea that is.”
What a mean-spirited, shallow-thinking man we have as a leader of our nation.
without a doubt, John Key has a constituency of many other selfish, mean-spirited, short-sighted people in this country. There are a fair number of ill-educated and self-centered who think that the only solution to poverty is to do nothing, and let the poor struggle on. These people have no compassion.
That is the kind of shallow-thinking that will eventually doom a society to growing income-disparity; increasing gap between the Haves and Have Nots; and eventual social dislocation and violence.
Such people who think that the poor are poor because they deserve it are a far greater menace to the fabric of our social cohesion, than all the patched gang-members in our community.
For John Key to dismiss a proposed Universal Child Benefit as “dopey” shows us only one thing; he has forgotten his roots. He has forgotten where he came from. He has forgotten not just the sacrifices of his family – but the strong community support that he benefitted from, and gave him the opportunity to make himself rich.
John Key is where he is because other taxpayers contributed to his housing, education, healthcare, and well-being.
He did not do it by himself.
This blogger does not begrudge Dear Leader’s bulging bank account of $50 million.
What I find reprehensible is that he would deny other families the chance to access similar support to give their children a decent start in life.
Paula Bennett did the same with the Training Incentive Allowance. Bennett used the TIA to gain a free tertiary education for herself – and then cut the Allowance in 2009. Other solo-mothers can no longer use the same TIA to put themselves through University, and get of the DPB.
This blogger wonders at the like of John Key and Paula Bennett, and how they can deny others the same state-funded assistance that they themselves benefitted from.
What kind of human beings are these people?
How can they forget the assistance that they received when in need?
And what possible satisfaction do they get when they deny state assistance to their fellow New Zealanders? Especially the same assistance that Key and Bennett personally benefitted from?
The greatest poverty that a society can endure is not monetary. It is a paucity of leadership. It is a lack of hope. And it is a disconnect in social compassion.
When we allow cruelty over compassion, then we are in deep trouble.
It is said that when facing a problem, the three challenges are,
- Identify the problem,
- Come up with solutions,
- Have the Will to implement those solution.
We know the problem.
We have the solutions.
Our leaders are still looking for #3.
Previous related blogposts
= fs =
Leave a Reply Cancel reply
For a better New Zealand…
~ Cleaner rivers
~ No deep-sea oil drilling
~ Less on Roads - more on Rail
~ Minimum wage @ $15 p/hr
~ Marriage equality
~ Strong, effective Unions
~ No secret free-trade deals
~ Breakfast/lunches in our schools
~ Introducing Civics into our school curriculum
~ Cut back on the liquor industry
~ A fairer, progressive tax system
~ Fully funded, free healthcare
~ Ditto for education, including Tertiary
~ Fund Pharmac for Pompe's Disease medication & other 'orphan' drugs
~ No state asset sales!
~ Rebuild public TV broadcasting!
~ Keeping farms in local ownership
~ Reduce poverty, like we reduced the toll for road-fatalities
~ Jobs, Jobs, Jobs!
~ Being nice to each other
- 2013 – Ongoing jobless talley
- Four schools to close in Aranui, Christchurch
- KGB, CIA, STASI, SIS… Facebook?!
- The Vote, Electricity, and Sex! (That’ll grab your attention!)
- A playful “tiff”?!
- The GCSB law – Oh FFS!!!
- He Couldn’t handle the Truth…
- Mediaworks, Solid Energy, and National Standards
- The GCSB – when plain english simply won’t do.
- Student Defaulters – to be arrested on sight at all borders
- Project Loon…
- Shafting our own children’s future? Hell yeah, why not!
- Radio NZ’s new CEO is announced…
- The fabulously talented Kim Hill…
- Is Labour snatching defeat from the jaws of Victorysaurus?
- 14 June – Issues of Interest
- For Edward Snowden…
- Solid Energy – A solid drama of facts, fibs, and fall-guys
- Citizen A: Martyn Bradbury, Chris Trotter & David Slack
- Judith Collins – Minister of Talking Crap
- Judith Collins, Peter Dunne, & Backbenches
- 12 June – Issues of Interest
- National Party spin on Aaron Gilmore and MMP
- 11 June – Issues of Interest
- Can we afford to have “a chat on food in schools”?